Products

Problems
we solve

We can help your business

Request a Free Demo / trial

Insights

Insights | Insights Featured
14 November, 2023

Excel: Sabotaging Software Testing Since 1987

Excel is not a test management tool

I love MS Excel and use it most working days. It is a powerful, flexible tool and is rightly seen as the Swiss army knife of the office world. However, using Microsoft Excel for test management is akin to using a spoon when you need a scalpel.

To put it bluntly, Excel is not just a suboptimal choice for modern test management; it’s an outright menace.

Look, I appreciate how tempting Excel can be. After all, everybody already has the tool installed on their machines. But even if you are skilled enough to create a test management solution in Excel, you should stop before you start.

Firstly, building a test management solution is not an effective way to spend your time and will not give your company a great ROI.

Secondly, no matter how advanced your solution, it won’t be fit for purpose – don’t take it personally; this is not due to your abilities but to Excel’s many limitations.

Finally, others have already done the heavy lifting and created great, professional, feature-rich test management tools for you

In this insight, I will mostly cover the second part above and dissect Excel’s shortcomings – from poor collaboration to the chaos of multiple spreadsheets. I’ll highlight Excel’s inherent risks, the associated effort, and how the absence of centralisation makes streamlined operations impossible.

I’ll also introduce robust alternatives to solve your test management problems and elevate your entire test management process.

Why I Needed to Write This Insight

After a recent conversation with a newly hired test manager, I was prompted to write this insight.

She had previously run a successful and effective test team at a major global enterprise but decided to take on a new challenge.

The company she’s moved to is struggling with testing and turned to her as a heavy hitter to come in and sort things out. This new company has loads of things going for them: great testers, an appreciation of the importance of testing, a willingness to invest time in quality assurance activities, etc.

Despite this positivity, a single, massive problem prevents them from moving forward. In her words, “Their use of Excel is the major thing holding them back”.

She explained at length how they have hundreds of spreadsheets and the chaos this system is causing. There is no single version of the truth, no easy way to track progress, no clarity on responsibilities, and no easy way to link defects to test runs. Essentially, there is no way to manage testing effectively.

Thankfully, the new employer has agreed to her recommendation of moving to professional tools, and these issues will soon be a thing of the past.

However, these issues are not unique, and I wanted to take this opportunity to delve into why this usually helpful and versatile tool can lead to so many test management issues.

6 Reasons Why Excel Is a Bad Choice For Test Management

Unfortunately, the issues faced above are not unique to her new employer. Because of this, I wanted to take this opportunity to delve into six reasons why this usually helpful and versatile tool can lead to so many test management issues.

1. Collaboration is a nightmare: Excel was never intended to be a multi-user platform.

Expecting multiple stakeholders like developers, testers, and product managers to collaborate seamlessly is a pipe-dream.

Every minute spent waiting for another team member to close the spreadsheet or trying to decipher conflicting versions is a minute wasted.

Excel can’t offer a single, centralised repository for all your test management needs. Instead, you end up with a jigsaw puzzle of files scattered across different systems and email chains, often missing several pieces.

2. Traceability is Non-existent: Test management is all about connections and visibility.

With Excel, your traceability is manual, cumbersome and error-prone. Keeping it up to date is practically impossible. Good luck ensuring quality without clearly mapping tests, defects, and requirements.

3. Forget about scalability: Excel crumbles under the weight of complex test management.

The tools you use must grow seamlessly with your project’s needs, accommodating larger datasets, more intricate dependencies, and an increasing number of stakeholders.

If you’re banking on Excel to scale with your needs, you’re setting yourself up for failure. As projects grow, the number of entries in an Excel sheet grows, and so does the file size. You can expect lags, crashes, and an ocean of fragmented sheets.

4. Reporting with Excel is an exercise in futility: Real-time dashboards are wishful thinking at best.

Effective reporting isn’t just about collating data; it’s about gleaning actionable insights. In test management, real-time, dynamic reports can be the difference between proactive problem-solving and reactive fire-fighting.

When pitted against this modern requirement, Excel’s reporting capabilities are woefully archaic.

Prepare to spend countless hours creating rudimentary reports that are obsolete the moment they’re done.

5. Maximum effort and maximum errors: Excel’s heavy reliance on manual input is a recipe for disaster.

It’s not a matter of if mistakes will happen, but when. And when they do, they’ll wreak havoc on your test management process.

Also, Excel’s security features are laughably inadequate for safeguarding sensitive project details. Every shared, lost, or misplaced Excel file is a potential data breach waiting to happen.

You’d expect that maybe it’s so error-prone because it requires little effort. Conversely, the opposite is true; the effort required to achieve even this nightmare scenario is astronomically high.

What could be achieved with a few clicks in a professional tool can take hours in Excel.

6. Test Automation Anyone? Automation is the wind beneath the wings of modern testing.

Without automation, processes are slower, more error-prone, and ill-suited for today’s fast-paced development environments.

In an era where automation is king, clinging to Excel for test management is akin to handicapping your testing potential.

It’s not just about doing more but doing it smarter, faster, and more accurately. Excel, sadly, is the antithesis of this automation-first approach.

Making the Switch: QC and Octane Are Vastly Superior Alternatives to Excel

Unlike Excel, professional test tools cater specifically to modern test management. Two such powerful tools are Quality Center (QC) and ALM Octane. Both are available for SaaS or on-premises.

4 Reasons to Love Quality Center (QC)

Quality Center is a testing thoroughbred; it is ideal for traditional waterfall based project and has the longest pedigree of any professional test tool.

1. A Centralised Repository: Unlike the fragmented world of Excel spreadsheets, QC provides a centralised database for all your testing assets. This means everything is in one place, from requirements to defects.

2. There’s Full Traceability: With QC, you can effortlessly link requirements to test cases and defects, ensuring that nothing falls through the cracks and every requirement is validated.

3. In-built and Robust Reporting: No more manual, outdated reports. QC’s built-in reporting capabilities offer real-time insights and customised reporting to meet your project’s unique needs.

4. Easily Integrate into Your Environment: QC integrates seamlessly with other tools in the software development lifecycle, allowing for a more streamlined and efficient workflow.

4 Reasons to Love ValueEdge Quality (previously ALM Octane)

ValueEdge Quality is based on ALM Octane, the incredibly succesful Agile and DevOps focused quality management solution.

1. It is Agile and DevOps Ready: Octane is designed for the modern software development lifecycle. Whether using Agile, Waterfall, or a hybrid approach, Octane has you covered.

2. It Supports Powerful Automation: Automate repetitive tasks, integrate with CI/CD tools, and ensure your testing keeps pace with rapid deployment cycles.

3. Collaboration at its Best: Octane promotes real-time team collaboration, ensuring everyone is aligned and working towards a common goal.

4. You Get Customisable Dashboards: Get a bird’s eye view of your entire project, from test coverage to defect trends, with Octane’s customisable dashboards.

Stop Sabotaging Your Software Testing Efforts

It’s nearly 2024. If you’re still using Excel for test management, you’re not just behind the curve; you’re actively undermining the efficiency, security, and effectiveness of your testing processes.

If you still think Excel will save your company money, think again.

Most companies report at least a 10% efficiency improvement by using a purpose-built Test Management tool. This more than offsets the cost.

There’s no excuse. It’s time to ditch the spreadsheets. Yes, Excel is familiar territory, but using it for test management is a costly mistake.

Upgrade to a dedicated test management tool.

Tools like QC and Octane are tailored for the complexities of modern testing, ensuring efficiency, collaboration, and quality.

The good news is that spreadsheets can be easily imported into most modern test tools, so the assets you have can form the foundation of your new Test Management tool.

By making the switch, you’re not just modernising your toolset but also significantly boosting your team’s productivity and the overall success rate of your projects.

Don’t let Excel sabotage your success. The time for change is now.

Stephen Davis
by Stephen Davis

Stephen Davis is the founder of Calleo Software, a OpenText (formerly Micro Focus) Gold Partner. His passion is to help test professionals improve the efficiency and effectiveness of software testing.

To view Stephen's LinkedIn profile and connect 

Stephen Davis LinkedIn profile

14th November 2023
Chatbots

Are General-Purpose Chatbots Good Enough for Software Testing?

You can manage software testing in Excel, but more often that not, it quickly becomes a pain in the behind. Recently, I’ve been wondering: does the same apply to AI Chatbots? After all, there are solid reasons why businesses invest in professional tools, rather than using general-purpose desktop solutions. Are there similar justifications for purpose-built testing AI tools?

Do Stakeholders Understand

Do Stakeholders Actually Understand the Purpose of Testing?

Most stakeholders don’t need to understand the finer points of software testing. They’ve got their own jobs to get on with. A finance director doesn’t need to know how to prepare test data, any more than a tester needs to understand how the finance director prepares the annual accounts. For the most part, this works well. Stakeholders get useful results, visibility of progress and enough information to make decisions. They don’t need a running commentary on everything that happens in a test environment. However, people can expect different things from those results.

testers v AI

Can Software Testers Save Mankind from AI?

In the race to protect us against rogue AI, our best defence might not be scientists or politicians, but the often-overlooked heroes of the tech world: software testers.

As AI systems increasingly mediate healthcare, criminal justice, and military decisions, this unlikely profession could hold the key to preventing existential catastrophe.

Real World UX

How to Test Real World Software Performance

When it comes to performance testing, whether you’re a seasoned expert or a complete novice, having the right tools at your disposal can make all the difference. Enter TruClient, a powerful solution designed to streamline the testing process for web and mobile applications. But what exactly makes TruClient such a valuable tool?

In essence, TruClient protocols allow you to test web and mobile applications quickly, easily and efficiently.

Most performance test scripting tools operate at a protocol level; however, TruClient records your actions in real-time, enabling faster scripting.

Evergreen Software Testing

How to Test Evergreen IT: A Very Short Guide

Evergreen IT sounds simple. Rather than running old systems for years, software is continuously updated. The benefits are obvious: access to new features, no more painful migration projects, better security, and less technical debt. This has knock-on effects for test teams. Evergreen IT reduces the need for large, occasional system

Testing has changed

Your Software Keeps Changing. Can Your Testing Keep Up?

Cloud applications, SaaS platforms, browsers, APIs and security services now update on schedules set largely by their suppliers.

Customers may be able to select a maintenance window or postpone an update briefly, but they usually cannot remain on the same version indefinitely.

The software industry often calls this evergreen software: solutions kept current through frequent, supplier-led updates instead of occasional, customer-controlled upgrades.

OT UFT One in 2026

Test Automation in 2026: Less Scripting, Easier Maintenance

Automation can and should help you release sooner and with more confidence. But it doesn’t always work out that way. It often creates its own delays, with scripts that only a few specialists can maintain, brittle checks that fail after routine interface changes and results that are, rightly, treated with scepticism.

The problem is, many people are still automating poorly, with dated approaches, fragmented automation solutions, and poor tool choices. Thankfully, in 2026, there’s a much easier way to automate functional testing.

ALM Octane in 2026

5 Ways to Know if Your Project is Really on Track

Is your software project on track? Do you really know? Are there hidden issues lurking in the background that will catch you out? Too often, the answers are buried in silos across different tools. By the time someone pulls everything together, some of the information is already out of date.

ALM Octane gives you instant access to up-to-date delivery information. It shows you the current state of quality, what is on track, what is holding delivery up and whether you have enough evidence to release with confidence.

Performance testing in 2026

These LoadRunner Cloud Updates Make Performance Testing Better in 2026

LoadRunner Cloud gives teams a SaaS platform for creating and running performance tests without having to build and maintain all the supporting load-generation infrastructure themselves.

Officially named OpenText Core Performance Engineering, LoadRunner Cloud can simulate anything from a small number of users to millions, across different locations, applications and technologies.

Software Testing Risk

Is Remote Software Testing Creating New Risks You Haven’t Even Considered?

Increasingly, organisations expect remote and hybrid testers to use borrowed tool licences, unstable VPNs, and software never designed to leave the office. That creates significant compliance and security risks that can turn into serious long‑term problems.

It’s not the testers per se, but remote execution over on‑prem licences is a software audit waiting to happen. Read on to learn why a compliance nightmare isn’t the only reason your test setup might not be fit for distributed and home‑working team members.

Insights

Search

Related Articles

To get other software testing insights, like this, direct to you inbox join the Calleo mailing list.

You can, of course, unsubscribe 

at any time!

By signing up you consent to receiving regular emails from Calleo with updates, tips and ideas on software testing along with the occasional promotion for software testing products. You can, of course, unsubscribe at any time. Click here for the privacy policy.

Sign up to receive the latest, Software Testing Insights, news and to join the Calleo mailing list.

You can, of course, unsubscribe at any time!

By signing up you consent to receiving regular emails from Calleo with updates, tips and ideas on software testing along with the occasional promotion for software testing products. You can, of course, unsubscribe at any time. Click here for the privacy policy.